A Defense Of Abortion By Judith Thompson - 1919 Words

PHILOSOPHY 2615 Melissa Ramessar 212762654 In this paper I am going to critically evaluate â€Å"A Defense of Abortion† by Judith Thompson, a moral philosopher and metaphysician, who argues that is morally okay to abort a fetus even if the fetus is considered a person and contrast it to another moral philosopher and utilitarian, Peter Singer who deems her argument to be flawed. Judith Thompson presents a scenario where you are the only person with a particular blood type needed to save a famous unconscious violinist’s life; the Society of Music Lovers finds and kidnaps you. They plug him into you in order to use your kidneys to save his life. They assure you it’s only for nine months and by that time it will be okay to remove the plug. Is this unconscious violinist considered a person? Should you be obligated to help him? What if the violinist is putting a strain on your kidneys and you ll be dead within a week, what should you do? According to Clifford Grobstein in â€Å"When Does Personhood Begin,† he states that, â€Å"Being a person involves subjective awareness, including personality, a sense of self awareness and consciousness.† Even though one may argue that the unconscious violinist is a person because he can go back to being a conscious person after the nine months and therefore you should help him; some may argue that though he has the potential he isn’t a person in the state he is in and therefore, you do not need to help him. Judith Thompson’s response to thisShow MoreRelatedIs Abortion Right Or Wrong?1116 Words   |  5 PagesIs abortion right or wrong? This is a big topic in today’s society. Abortion is always brought up whether it’s religion, politics, or just in a regular conversation. Although, the question remains; is it right or is it wrong? There are many arguments about it. There are an abundant amount of people that argue with each other over this topic. These, however, are opinion-based arguments. There are many points and articles against abortion. There is also information about options for women who regretRead MoreAbortion Essay1583 Words   |  7 Pageswill be discussing the topic of abortion. I have chosen R.M. Hare, and Judith Jarvis Thompson as two candidates from the book the â€Å"The Moral life† by Steve Luper, and Curtis Brown. I will be discussing the critique, and defense of abortion. I will be presenting, analyzing and critically evaluating the writer s view on the topic, then I will be discussing my own views about the issue of abortion, and how the arguments of the two writers guide the conclusion of abortion. R.M. Hare’s argument in â€Å"A KantianRead MoreA Defense Of Abortion By Judith Jarvis Thomson951 Words   |  4 PagesIn Judith Jarvis Thomson’s A Defense of Abortion, Thomson explores the relationship between the rights of a fetus and the rights of a human, in this case the mother. Thomson is an American moral philosopher and meta-physician. She is known for her defense of moral objectivity, her account of moral rights, her views about the incompleteness of the term good, and her use of thought experiments to make philosophical points. In the article, Thomson defends abortions in several certain circumstancesRead MoreDebate Over The Issue Of Abortion2043 Words   |  9 Pages210 Dr. Pierce Paper 3 Comprehensive Debate Over The Issue of Abortion The issue of abortion is has been widely debated for many years and still continues to lead headlines today. It sparks debates in classrooms, courtrooms, and family rooms across the country as the issue is so complex, there are a variety of views and responses to its morality and legality. To understand the current debate over the issues concerning abortion we must not look at this issue from a black and white perspectiveRead MoreEssay on Analysis of Thompsons Article, A Defense of Abortion1760 Words   |  8 PagesPro-Choice: Analysis of Thompsons Article, A Defense of Abortion Works Cited Missing In Judith Jarvis Thompson’s article â€Å"A Defense of Abortion† she explores the different arguments against abortion presented by Pro –Life activists, and then attempts to refute these notions using different analogies or made up â€Å"for instances† to help argue her point that women do have the right to get an abortion. She explains why abortion is morally permissible using different circumstances ofRead More A Womans Right to Choose Essay876 Words   |  4 PagesA Womans Right to Choose During the past quarter century, abortion has joined race and war as one of the most popular subjects of controversy in the United States. Abortion poses a moral, social and medical dilemma that challenges the way many of us think and feel. There are many points of view toward abortion but the only two fine distinctions are pro-choice and pro-life. A pro-choicer would feel that the decision to abort a pregnancy is that of the mothers and the state has no right toRead MoreWhy Abortion Is Permissible? Essay1587 Words   |  7 Pagesthe most widely debated moral issues is abortion, which is defined as the termination of a pregnancy followed by the death of the embryo or fetus. The point of contention on abortion is that we are putting two lives in jeopardy, the mother’s and fetus’ life. Although this issue is highly discussed, debaters, especially opponents, fail to provide explicit and extensive analysis as it is pointed out by Judith J. Thomson in her article ‘‘A Defense of Abortion.† In this article, I will be rehearsingRead MoreAn Essay Of Two Abortion Arguments1701 Words   |  7 PagesEssay of Two Abortion Arguments) Philosophers, lawyers, theologians and others have devoted and continue to devote their lives to study of the ethics of abortion. Since abortion was legalized, the abortion debate has intensified, and does not show any signs of being resolved anytime soon. The idea’s that advocate the women’s right to abort or the proactive logic that supports the pro-life view and the fundamental identity of the baby all come in hand when looking at the ethics of abortion .AmericanRead MoreThe Ethics of Contraception Essay915 Words   |  4 Pagescontraception, that can be taken if other methods of birth control have failed or were absent. It works by causing the lining of the uterus to shed, taking the potentially fertilized ovum with it (â€Å"contraception† 2005). These two methods are often considered abortion because some individuals view the fertilized egg as a human life that is deserving of the right to life, the most basic of human rights. Utilitarianism does not comp letely oppose the use of contraception; it weighs the outcomes of every situationRead MoreEssay on Judith Jarvis Thomson: a Defense of Abortion1946 Words   |  8 PagesJudith Jarvis Thomson: A Defense of Abortion – CRITICAL EXPOSITION The goal of Judith Jarvis Thomson in her defense of abortion is to sway the ideas of those who are against abortion by challenging the arguments they give for thinking so. She begins by stating a premise. â€Å"For the sake of the argument† a human embryo is a person. This premise is one of the arguments most opponents of abortion use, but as she points out, isn’t much of an argument at all. These people spend a lot of their time dwelling